Maybelline
around $14
857 Pros
75%
42 reviews (8h 10m)
287 Cons
Maybelline's Super Stay Up to 24HR Skin Tint offers a tempting blend of lightweight coverage and radiant finish. Reviewers rave about its natural, "skin-like" look, praising its ability to even out skin tone, blur pores, and create a healthy glow without feeling heavy or cakey. Many appreciate the buildable coverage, finding it versatile enough fo...
87%
180 vs 28
80%
160 vs 41
81%
117 vs 28
81%
156 vs 36
88%
63 vs 9
Across 42 YouTube reviews, the Maybelline Super Stay Up to 24HR Skin Tint earns an Index score of 4/5, ranking #17 among Face (Foundation, Concealer, Blush). Reviewers most often praise its finish, texture/feel, longevity, while the most common criticisms concern texture/feel, shade range.
The Maybelline Super Stay Up to 24HR Skin Tint is widely praised for delivering a natural, skin-like radiant finish that reviewers frequently call lightweight and fresh-looking (finish cited 53 times). Many reviewers also highlight strong longevity and resistance to transfer or fading across wear tests (longevity cited 41 times). The formula’s texture and feel are repeatedly noted as weightless, silky, and easy to blend, making it feel like nothing on the skin (texture/feel cited 39 times). Reviewers additionally report buildable, light-to-medium coverage that evens skin tone without masking features, and they appreciate the value for a drugstore price and the presence of vitamin C in the formula (coverage 35 mentions; value and formula mentioned multiple times).
Critics most often point to texture issues, reporting that the tint can emphasize pores, cling in textured areas, or feel slightly tacky/thicker than expected (texture/feel cons cited 24 times). Longevity claims are questioned by several reviewers who experienced transfer, wear-off in oily areas, or settling into lines and creasing rather than true 24-hour performance (longevity cons cited 24 times). The formula and finish receive negative notes about odor, thickness/oxidation, and visible shimmer or pearlescence that can look makeup-y or highlight texture for some users (formula 20 mentions; finish 17 mentions). Additional common drawbacks include shade selection and undertone mismatches for some reviewers and dislike of the dropper packaging (shade range 14 mentions; packaging 10 mentions).
Analysis based on 42 YouTube reviews (8h 10m of video) with 857 pros and 287 cons extracted.
Based on 42 independent YouTube reviews, the Maybelline Super Stay Up to 24HR Skin Tint scores 4/5 with 857 positive and 287 negative points mentioned by reviewers, placing it #17 in the Face (Foundation, Concealer, Blush) category.
The most praised aspects are finish, texture/feel, longevity — Finish (180 mentions), Texture/Feel (160 mentions), Longevity (156 mentions).
Reviewers most frequently criticize texture/feel, shade range — Texture/Feel (41 mentions), Shade Range (39 mentions).
Spotted an error? Help me improve by reporting it!
Find this helpful? Please consider a donation!
☕Buy me a coffee