Super Stay Skin Tint
Image source:
RANKING
9
Rank 9 out of 89 Summarized in this category Rankings based on: • Pros-to-cons ratio • Number of reviews • Category average

Maybelline

Super Stay Skin Tint

around $13

i
All prices are estimates and may vary from actual prices.

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases through affiliate links.

844 Pros

77%
40 reviews (7h 43m)

259 Cons

Achieve a naturally radiant, healthy-looking complexion with Maybelline's Super Stay Skin Tint. This lightweight formula delivers light to medium, buildable coverage that blurs imperfections and creates a smooth, skin-like finish. Infused with Vitamin C, it promises to gradually brighten your skin over time. Reviewers rave about its comfortable, ...

Summary of pros and cons from human reviewers, put together by AI

87%

185 vs 27

Finish

80%

130 vs 32

Texture/Feel

77%

118 vs 35

Coverage

78%

159 vs 45

Longevity

96%

88 vs 4

Overall

Reviewer verdict

Across 40 YouTube reviews, the Maybelline Super Stay Skin Tint earns an Index score of 4.1/5, ranking #9 among Face (Foundation, Concealer, Blush). Reviewers most often praise its finish, longevity, texture/feel, while the most common criticisms concern longevity, coverage.

Reviewers consistently praise the Maybelline Super Stay Skin Tint for its strong longevity and transfer resistance, with many noting it lasts through full workdays, heat, sweat, and up to double-digit hours (multiple mentions across reviews). They also frequently highlight its natural, skin-like radiant finish and lightweight, breathable texture that feels comfortable and not heavy on the face. Coverage is commonly described as light-to-medium and buildable, giving a skin-like evenness without looking cakey, and several reviewers appreciated the vitamin C–infused formula and generally good shade matches across the available range. Overall sentiment across the 40 reviews skews positive on wear time, finish, feel, and practical shade availability and value for a drugstore product.

Criticisms center on wear issues for some skin types: many reviewers reported shine, settling into smile lines or around the nose, and break-up for oilier skin or after extended wear despite overall longevity claims. The shade selection and matching process drew frequent complaints about undertones, difficulty choosing online, and limits to the range, and the formula was called finicky or prone to pilling and clumping with certain primers, sunscreens, or moisturizers. Other recurring negatives include tacky or slightly heavy-feeling areas, packaging frustrations with the dropper (messy and not ideal for a vitamin C product), and concerns about alcohol content and potential dryness for sensitive or very dry skin.

Analysis based on 40 YouTube reviews (7h 43m of video) with 844 pros and 259 cons extracted.

Pros (844)

Finish (185)
Longevity (159)
Texture/Feel (130)
Coverage (118)
Overall (88)
Application (47)
Formula (40)
Shade Range (33)
Value (20)
Skin Compatibility (18)
Packaging (4)
Evenness (2)

Cons (259)

Longevity (45)
Coverage (35)
Texture/Feel (32)
Formula (27)
Finish (27)
Shade Range (26)
Packaging (25)
Skin Compatibility (20)
Application (11)
Value (7)
Overall (4)

Review sources

Frequently asked questions

Is the Maybelline Super Stay Skin Tint worth buying?

Based on 40 independent YouTube reviews, the Maybelline Super Stay Skin Tint scores 4.1/5 with 844 positive and 259 negative points mentioned by reviewers, placing it #9 in the Face (Foundation, Concealer, Blush) category.

What do reviewers like most about the Maybelline Super Stay Skin Tint?

The most praised aspects are finish, longevity, texture/feel — Finish (185 mentions), Longevity (159 mentions), Texture/Feel (130 mentions).

What are the most common complaints about the Maybelline Super Stay Skin Tint?

Reviewers most frequently criticize longevity, coverage — Longevity (45 mentions), Coverage (35 mentions).

Spotted an error? Help me improve by reporting it!

Find this helpful? Please consider a donation!

☕Buy me a coffee