Maybelline
Super Stay 24H Skin Tint
around $13

Maybelline
around $13
832 Pros
78%
42 reviews (8h 2m)
235 Cons
Maybelline's Super Stay 24H Skin Tint offers a tempting blend of lightweight coverage and radiant finish. Reviewers rave about its comfortable, weightless feel and natural, skin-like look, with many achieving a beautiful, healthy glow. The buildable formula allows for light to medium coverage, adaptable to your needs, while the vitamin C infusion...
89%
143 vs 18
84%
133 vs 26
85%
114 vs 20
80%
134 vs 33
98%
88 vs 2
Across 42 YouTube reviews, the Maybelline Super Stay 24H Skin Tint earns an Index score of 4.1/5, ranking #5 among Face (Foundation, Concealer, Blush). Reviewers most often praise its finish, longevity, texture/feel, while the most common criticisms concern shade range, longevity.
The Maybelline Super Stay 24H Skin Tint is widely praised for its longwearing performance, with many reviewers (55 mentions) saying it resists sweat, humidity, fading and stays put for most of the day. Reviewers also frequently highlight its buildable light-to-medium coverage (40 mentions) that can cover blemishes without feeling heavy, and a natural, radiant finish (40 mentions) that makes skin look healthy and blurred rather than cakey. Multiple reviewers compliment the formula and texture (36 and 18 mentions) as ultra-lightweight, breathable and easy to blend, and several note decent shade matches and packaging features like the dropper (12 and 2 mentions). Overall many creators call it a strong drugstore skin tint that delivers long wear, skin-like coverage and a comfortable weightless feel (17 overall “overall” praises).
Critics most often call out shade range and undertone issues (34 mentions), reporting that several shades are too warm, dark, or hard to pick online and that the selection could be expanded. Longevity concerns also appear in the cons (26 mentions), particularly for oilier skin types where reviewers report breakdown around the nose, forehead shine, transfer with cream products, and that the 24-hour claim can feel exaggerated. A number of reviewers mention texture and finish problems (16 and 9 mentions) such as accentuated texture, occasional clumpiness or shimmer, and some dryness or flaking for drier skin; formulation and packaging criticisms (12 and 9 mentions) include a runny formula, possible alcohol scent, and messy dropper packaging. Several reviewers also note unevenness or settling into fine lines in certain areas (8 mentions), and modest concerns about coverage trade-offs (13 mentions).
Analysis based on 42 YouTube reviews (8h 2m of video) with 832 pros and 235 cons extracted.
Based on 42 independent YouTube reviews, the Maybelline Super Stay 24H Skin Tint scores 4.1/5 with 832 positive and 235 negative points mentioned by reviewers, placing it #5 in the Face (Foundation, Concealer, Blush) category.
The most praised aspects are finish, longevity, texture/feel — Finish (143 mentions), Longevity (134 mentions), Texture/Feel (133 mentions).
Reviewers most frequently criticize shade range, longevity — Shade Range (39 mentions), Longevity (33 mentions).
Spotted an error? Help me improve by reporting it!
Find this helpful? Please consider a donation!
☕Buy me a coffee