Hollow Knight: Silksong
Image source:
RANKING
29
Rank 29 out of 29 Summarized in this category Rankings based on: • Pros-to-cons ratio • Number of reviews • Category average

Team Cherry

Hollow Knight: Silksong

around $30

i
All prices are estimates and may vary from actual prices.

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases through affiliate links.

288 Pros

61%
26 reviews (4h 40m)

186 Cons

Embark on a vast adventure through a new, haunted kingdom in *Hollow Knight: Silksong*. As the agile protector Hornet, you will leap, dash, and battle your way through a world brought to life with breathtaking, hand-drawn art and a magnificent orchestral score. The core of what made the original a masterpiece remains, but it’s expanded in every way...

Summary of pros and cons from human reviewers, put together by AI

51%

170 vs 166

Gameplay

97%

35 vs 1

Story & Narrative

86%

19 vs 3

Graphics & Visuals

56%

9 vs 7

Originality & Innovation

95%

19 vs 1

Sound & Music

Reviewer verdict

Across 26 YouTube reviews, the Team Cherry Hollow Knight: Silksong earns an Index score of 3.4/5, ranking #29 among Indie Games. Reviewers most often praise its gameplay, story & narrative, sound & music, while the most common criticisms concern gameplay, controls & user interface.

Hollow Knight: Silksong is widely praised for its refined, fast, and highly satisfying gameplay loop, with reviewers frequently highlighting improved movement, a deep combat toolkit (crests, tools, and abilities), and an abundance of challenging, meticulously designed boss encounters; gameplay-related praise appears in the majority of notes (143 of 288 pro mentions). Critics also consistently applaud the enormous, handcrafted world full of secrets and rewarding exploration, the evocative art direction and visuals, and Christopher Larkin’s standout score, with multiple reviewers noting excellent performance and strong value for content. Many reviewers emphasize Hornet’s nimble controls, quality-of-life improvements (like mid-air healing and ledge grabs), and a robust mission/quest system that makes the narrative and progression more approachable. Across the sampled reviews there is a strong consensus that Silksong builds on the original’s strengths while expanding scope, polish, and mechanical depth.

Most criticisms center on the game’s high difficulty, punishing runbacks, sparse or costly checkpoints, and opaque progression that can leave players stuck or forced into tedious grinding; gameplay issues account for the bulk of negative mentions (136 of 186 cons). Reviewers repeatedly call out problematic level or area design (notably brutal runbacks in areas like Bilewater), an unforgiving early difficulty spike, and side-quests or economy systems that feel tedious or poorly balanced (bench costs, scarce currency, and merchant-tied tools). Additional concerns include some awkward default mechanics (diagonal pogo, mandatory compass/tool slots, and limited control customization) and spots where visuals or music don’t always top the original, leaving a minority feeling the sequel refines rather than reinvents the formula. Overall, reviewers agree the core game is excellent but that difficulty, checkpoint placement, and certain design choices hamper accessibility and pacing.

Analysis based on 26 YouTube reviews (4h 40m of video) with 288 pros and 186 cons extracted.

Pros (288)

Gameplay (170)
Story & Narrative (35)
Sound & Music (19)
Graphics & Visuals (19)
Content & Value (18)
Controls & User Interface (10)
Originality & Innovation (9)
Performance & Stability (5)
Replayability (3)

Cons (186)

Gameplay (166)
Controls & User Interface (8)
Originality & Innovation (7)
Graphics & Visuals (3)
Story & Narrative (1)
Sound & Music (1)

Review sources

Frequently asked questions

Is the Team Cherry Hollow Knight: Silksong worth buying?

Based on 26 independent YouTube reviews, the Team Cherry Hollow Knight: Silksong scores 3.4/5 with 288 positive and 186 negative points mentioned by reviewers, placing it #29 in the Indie Games category.

What do reviewers like most about the Team Cherry Hollow Knight: Silksong?

The most praised aspects are gameplay, story & narrative, sound & music — Gameplay (170 mentions), Story & Narrative (35 mentions), Sound & Music (19 mentions).

What are the most common complaints about the Team Cherry Hollow Knight: Silksong?

Reviewers most frequently criticize gameplay, controls & user interface — Gameplay (166 mentions), Controls & User Interface (8 mentions).

Spotted an error? Help me improve by reporting it!

Find this helpful? Please consider a donation!

☕Buy me a coffee
Team Cherry Hollow Knight: Silksong - Pros Cons Index